Sacramento advances water and wastewater rate plan to Proposition 218 hearing
City of Sacramento Department of Utilities, California · Meeting date: November 17, 2026 · Published: November 18, 2026
The council accepted staff responses to 12 valid written objections and authorised the next stage of its rate-setting process. The Utilities Rate Advisory Commission will hold the public protest hearing on 2 December, ahead of planned council consideration in early 2027.
Key points
- Council approved the resolution accepting written objections and staff responses, allowing the Proposition 218 hearing to proceed on 2 December 2026.
- The city received 18 written objections; staff found 12 to be valid and timely under the new objection process established by Assembly Bill 2257.
- Objections challenged the proposed fixed-charge allocation, uniform water volumetric rate and revised residential wastewater structure, particularly their effects on low-use and low-income customers.
- The proposed schedules would apply for fiscal years beginning 1 July 2027 through 2031; staff said formal council adoption would be considered in early 2027.
- Sacramento said its existing utility-assistance programme offsets about 40% of bills for income-qualified customers and is funded at $5.4 million annually from Measure U revenues.
Full report
Sacramento City Council has moved its proposed water and wastewater rate adjustments into the formal Proposition 218 protest process, approving staff responses to objections that focused on affordability, fixed charges and whether the city’s proposed rate structures fairly allocate costs among customers.
The council voted to accept the objections and responses and to allow the Department of Utilities to proceed to a 2 December public protest hearing before the Utilities Rate Advisory Commission. The proposed schedules cover fiscal years beginning 1 July 2027 through 2031. Staff said the commission will receive public testimony and make recommendations before the matter returns to council for formal rate consideration in early 2027.
The city received 18 written objections, of which 12 were deemed valid and timely. The process is separate from the conventional Proposition 218 protest count: written objections are intended to preserve a ratepayer’s ability to bring a legal challenge, while a majority protest would prevent adoption of the proposed rates.
David Levine, the Department of Utilities’ long-range financial planning manager, told the council that the objections principally argued that the proposed rates assign too much cost to fixed charges, retain a uniform water volumetric rate rather than a residential tiered structure, and disproportionately affect low-water-use and low-income households.
One objection cited in the meeting argued that a 1-inch-meter customer’s fixed water charge would rise substantially under the proposal and that low-use households would face a much higher fixed-cost share of their bill. Another challenged a proposed move from residential wastewater charges based on room count to a flat charge by dwelling type, arguing that smaller homes would face larger increases while larger homes could see lower charges.
Utilities staff and outside legal counsel said the city’s existing wastewater room-count methodology could not be supported by available cost-of-service data. The proposed wastewater structure instead uses census-based household-density assumptions to distinguish between single-family and multifamily customers. Staff said another potential approach—using winter water consumption as a wastewater proxy—would require data and billing-system capabilities the city does not currently have.
For water service, staff said the proposed structure would recover roughly half of revenue through fixed charges and half through variable use charges, compared with about 62% fixed-cost recovery in the current rate structure. Department of Utilities director Dalia Fadl said customers would still control the variable half of their bills through water use, while fixed revenues are needed for costs such as treatment plants, personnel and other infrastructure that do not vary with consumption.
Councilmembers pressed staff on whether the city should collect further data to assess a future tiered or usage-based structure. Staff said it would examine what data and system changes would be needed, while noting that current California case law has made tiered-rate designs difficult to defend without detailed supporting data. The city’s legal counsel said a pending California Supreme Court case concerning tiered water rates could take one to two years to resolve.
Levine said Sacramento’s Utility Rate Assistance Program, funded by $5.4 million a year from the General Fund’s Measure U revenues, offsets about 40% of bills for qualifying customers. The department expects to seek additional council funding as proposed rate adjustments increase the number of customers needing assistance.
This summary was generated by AI based on the source document and may contain errors.
Source: City Council - 5PM, City of Sacramento Department of Utilities