Palo Alto targets SFPUC drought model over rate and rationing risk
City of Palo Alto Utilities, California · Meeting date: November 16, 2026 · Published: November 17, 2026
Palo Alto City Council and its Utilities Advisory Commission have pressed the case for a review of SFPUC’s design drought, which underpins regional reliability planning for the Hetch Hetchy system. BAWSCA has now formally asked SFPUC to reassess the duration and severity of the planning scenario.
Key points
- Palo Alto’s 2025 Urban Water Management Plan projects local rationing of up to 48% in multiple dry years under the Bay Delta Plan implementation scenario, compared with no rationing if the amendments are not implemented.
- BAWSCA CEO and General Manager Tom Smigiel said he sent SFPUC a letter requesting a review of its design drought, established in 1992 by combining the 1986-92 and 1976-77 droughts into an 8.5-year sequence.
- SFPUC alternative water supply investments would flow through into Palo Alto’s wholesale water commodity cost, while drought cutbacks could activate Palo Alto’s local drought surcharge.
- SFPUC’s current alternative water supply planning identifies a dry-year supply gap of about 92mgd by 2045 under the Bay Delta Plan scenario; the gap rises to as much as 122mgd when measured against supply obligations.
- SFPUC declined Palo Alto’s invitation to join the study session, saying it preferred collective engagement with wholesale customers.
Full report
Palo Alto has sharpened its scrutiny of the drought assumptions behind San Francisco’s regional water planning, warning that an 8.5-year design drought could translate into steep customer rationing and higher rates if it prompts unnecessary alternative-supply investment.
At a joint study session with the Utilities Advisory Commission on 16 November, the council examined the reliability assumptions used by the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC), Palo Alto’s wholesale supplier. The city receives its potable supply from SFPUC’s Regional Water System: about 85% originates in the Tuolumne River watershed and is delivered through the Hetch Hetchy aqueducts, while about 15% comes from SFPUC local watersheds and facilities.
The stakes are substantial for Palo Alto. Its 2025 Urban Water Management Plan projects local rationing of up to 48% during multiple drought years if the State Water Resources Control Board’s Bay Delta Plan amendments are implemented. The same plan anticipates no rationing in multiple dry years if the amendments are not implemented.
The Bay Delta Plan amendments, adopted in 2018 but not yet self-implementing, require releases of 30-50% of unimpaired flow from the Stanislaus, Merced and Tuolumne rivers between February and June. Palo Alto supported the amendments in 2018. SFPUC is also pursuing a voluntary Healthy Rivers and Landscapes Programme, which staff said could lead to less severe Regional Water System drought cutbacks than the current amendment framework.
The focal point of the discussion was SFPUC’s design drought: an 8.5-year sequence combining the 1986-92 and 1976-77 droughts, developed in 1992. SFPUC uses the scenario to test long-term system reliability and has a system-wide level-of-service objective of no more than 20% rationing. Critics at the meeting argued the scenario is overly severe and does not reflect demand trends or hydrological evidence.
BAWSCA, which represents 26 SFPUC wholesale customers including Palo Alto, has now formally asked SFPUC to revisit the analysis. BAWSCA CEO and General Manager Tom Smigiel said he sent a letter requesting a review of the severity and duration of the design drought. He said SFPUC’s operational knowledge would be necessary for any meaningful assessment and cautioned that the result could either reduce or increase projected reliability needs.
“A couple of possible outcomes” exist, Smigiel said. A less severe planning scenario could reduce concern over alternative-water-supply development, while a finding that the system needs to plan for a more severe drought could lead to further capital investment.
Palo Alto’s concern is financial as well as operational. Staff said SFPUC alternative water supply programme costs would ultimately enter the wholesale commodity rate charged to Palo Alto and other customers. Regional drought cutbacks would also trigger Palo Alto’s local drought surcharge.
SFPUC’s 2024 Alternative Water Supply Plan identified six projects, although three have since been deferred and one cancelled. The remaining schemes are Pure Water Peninsula, initially expected to provide 6mgd of potable water with a possible additional 6mgd future phase, and South Bay Purified Water, expected to provide 10mgd of purified water for San Jose and Santa Clara demands while releasing additional Regional Water System supply in dry years. Even with both projects, SFPUC projects a dry-year shortfall of about 92mgd by 2045 under the Bay Delta Plan scenario, rising to as much as 122mgd against supply obligations.
Vice Mayor Greer Stone, Palo Alto’s BAWSCA representative, said the central concern was that an unrealistic design drought could lead SFPUC to build alternative supplies “that are not necessary and will cost tens of billions of dollars to build,” with those costs passed through to wholesale customers. He said BAWSCA lacks a veto over SFPUC capital projects, but that its customers collectively account for about two-thirds of Regional Water System demand.
Palo Alto staff recommended continued engagement through BAWSCA rather than a city-led independent reliability assessment, which they said would require unbudgeted technical capacity and significant resources. BAWSCA has estimated that a review of SFPUC’s design drought could take one to three years and cost $1m-$3m, excluding SFPUC staff involvement. SFPUC has no major alternative-supply construction spending shown until the end of its current 10-year capital programme, according to Smigiel, with significant investment expected in the mid-2030s.
This summary was generated by AI based on the source document and may contain errors.
Source: City Council Regular Meeting, City of Palo Alto Utilities