Prescott Valley weighs retreat from rental-development water rule
Town of Prescott Valley, Arizona · Meeting date: November 12, 2026 · Published: November 16, 2026
Prescott Valley’s proposed repeal of its non-subdivision water ordinance exposed a sharp divide between the town’s litigation concerns and residents’ calls to preserve a local safeguard on groundwater-dependent development.
Key points
- Ordinance No. 2023-930, adopted in January 2024, requires non-subdivision residential developments to secure commitments for renewable or imported water supplies before receiving town approvals.
- Town staff recommended repeal after the Goldwater Institute challenged the town’s authority and asserted that the ordinance conflicts with the Arizona Groundwater Management Act.
- The original measure sought to preserve the remaining Assured Water Supply Program allocation buffer for commercial, retail, industrial and governmental services in the Prescott Active Management Area.
- Residents urged the council to retain the rule, arguing that rental and apartment developments should face water-supply requirements comparable to those imposed on subdivisions.
Full report
Prescott Valley Town Council confronted a choice between maintaining a locally imposed water-supply condition on rental development and avoiding a potential legal fight, as it considered repeal of Ordinance No. 2023-930.
The 2024 ordinance requires non-subdivision residential projects to obtain commitments for renewable supplies, including effluent interests or available extinguishment credits, or imported water before obtaining town approvals. Residential subdivisions are separately required to obtain Certificates of Assured Water Supply from the Arizona Department of Water Resources.
The town adopted the measure after identifying the need to preserve the remaining buffer of Assured Water Supply Program allocation for commercial, retail, industrial and governmental services. Prescott Valley is within the Prescott Active Management Area, which ADWR declared was not in safe groundwater yield in 1999.
Town Attorney Ivan Legler said staff had reluctantly recommended repeal because three groups could potentially bring actions against the town. The Goldwater Institute had argued that the ordinance conflicted with the Arizona Groundwater Management Act and that the town lacked authority to enact it, requesting rescission or warning of litigation by affected property owners.
Legler said the town also faced possible expenditure on legal defence and other risks involving state-shared revenues. He added that staff was pursuing legislation and considering other future ordinances.
Public speakers overwhelmingly asked the council not to remove the requirement. They argued that, without it, apartment and other rental projects could proceed without demonstrating sufficient water, while subdivisions remained subject to assured-water-supply rules. Several speakers called for the town to wait for a formal legal claim or for state legislation intended to close what they described as a regulatory loophole.
One council member said there was no need to rush because litigation had not been filed and argued that repeal could still be considered later if circumstances changed. The mayor countered that the council had received legal advice and said an alternative ordinance could potentially be developed later with revisions intended to comply with Arizona law.
After the clerk read the proposed repealing ordinance by title, the mayor put the final-passage question to the council. In discussion after adjournment, a council member asked whether the matter could be reconsidered, citing concerns that repeal could prompt a referendum. Legler said a motion for reconsideration could be made at the next council meeting by a member who had voted with the majority.
This summary was generated by AI based on the source document and may contain errors.
Source: Town Council Regular Meeting, Town of Prescott Valley